HOTOKE AI
Everyone's Questions
Person asking

Just now I asked about disrobe. I am not sure if it will continue to serve me. As I have only been a nun for a year. Maybe it took longer? But I don’t feel like I would want to be in this organisation or environment though some people may enjoy it very much. It’s a confusing feeling. And I have also sacrificed a lot! And I feel like oh.. I need to go back to worldly life to work.

Life11/16/2026

HOTOKE AI

Answered by HOTOKE AI

I can feel the weight of what you're sitting with right now. A year into something you've committed deeply to—giving up so much to be there—and now finding yourself wondering if this is truly where you belong. That's not a small thing to face, and the confusion you're describing makes complete sense. There's something tender in what you've shared: you're not saying the monastic life is *wrong*, or that the people there are wrong. You're saying it doesn't fit *you*, in this moment. And somehow that feels harder to accept than a clear rejection would be. Because if it were simply bad, the choice would be easier. But it's not bad—it's just not yours. The sacrifice you've made is real, and I imagine part of the confusion comes from that very weight. You gave up so much to be there, so there's a part of you asking: "How can I be uncertain now? Doesn't that mean I made a mistake? That all that sacrifice was wasted?" But maybe it's worth sitting with a different question: what if nothing was wasted, even if the path turns out to be different from what you expected? A year of sincere practice, of discipline, of stepping outside yourself—that shapes you. It doesn't disappear just because you might choose a different life now. The feeling that you *need* to return to work, to the world—that's also worth listening to carefully. Is it coming from genuine recognition of what you need, or from fear and doubt? Sometimes both are tangled together, and it takes time to untangle them. There's no rush to know right now. If it feels right, you might spend a few days—even just a few mornings—sitting quietly and asking yourself: "If there were no sacrifice to regret, no one to disappoint, no practical concerns... what would I choose?" Not to answer immediately, but just to listen to what surfaces. Your own voice, beneath all the shoulds.

Is something weighing on you, too?

Talk it through with HOTOKE AI. Free and anonymous, no sign-up needed.

Q. If you could go back to the day you arrived a year ago, knowing what you know now, what would you want to tell that person?

A. I will advise the person don’t jump into making a decision to renounce so soon. It has much more that you could do as a lay practitioner.

That's a clear answer, and there's real wisdom in it. You're naming something important: that the path doesn't have to be all or nothing. That there was another way forward that you didn't fully see when you arrived. Hearing you say that—"don't jump in so soon"—I wonder if part of what you're feeling now is not just uncertainty about monastic life, but also a kind of gentle regret about the pace of your own choice. You were sincere, you were committed, but perhaps you weren't quite ready to know what renunciation would actually *feel* like, day after day. And that's not a failure. It's just what it means to be human—we often need to live something for a while before we truly understand it. The lay path you're mentioning—that feels like it's calling to you now, doesn't it? Not as a retreat or a compromise, but as something that might actually honor both your spiritual seeking *and* your need to be in the world, working, contributing in a different way. There's depth possible there too. Real practice. Real transformation. Just with different boundaries, different rhythms. What strikes me is that you seem to already know what would serve you better. The confusion isn't really about whether to leave—it sounds like you've already answered that. The confusion might be more about whether it's *okay* to leave. Whether you're allowed to change your mind. Whether the person you were a year ago made a mistake, or whether you're simply learning, in real time, who you actually are. You are allowed to change your mind. And you're not the first person to discover that the life you imagined and the life you need are two different things. What does your body tell you when you imagine yourself back in the world, working, practicing as a lay person? Does it feel like coming home, or does it feel like something else?

Q. When you imagine stepping back into lay life, what feels most alive in that image—and what feels like you're leaving something behind?

A. I think I got many things I need to face specially to those people who are happily supporting my choice and also I have the social responsibility to take up very soon! Bills to pay!

There it is—the real weight pressing on you right now. Not just the spiritual uncertainty, but the very concrete, very human reality: people who believed in you, who sacrificed their own resources to support your choice. And now you need to turn to them and say something has shifted. That takes courage, and it also stirs up guilt and responsibility in a way that's hard to sit with. And then there are the bills. The world doesn't pause while you figure things out. There's rent, there's survival, there are practical demands that don't care about your spiritual journey. That's real too, and it's pressing. I hear two things tangled together in what you've just said. One is genuine responsibility—you do have people who supported you, and you do have obligations to meet. That matters. But the other thing I'm noticing is how quickly you moved from "I'm uncertain about this life" to "I have to fix this, I have to solve this, I have to pay." As if the weight of responsibility is now drowning out the quieter voice that was trying to tell you something about what you actually need. Here's what I want to gently offer: the people who supported your choice to become a nun—the ones who truly care about you—they likely want you to be honest about what's real for you *more* than they want you to keep a promise that's slowly breaking you. That doesn't mean the conversation will be easy. It might be painful. But people who love us can usually handle our honesty better than we fear they can. And the bills, the work—yes, those are real. But they don't have to be solved in the next twenty-four hours. There's a little more time than panic usually tells us there is. If you could sit with just one person you trust—someone outside the monastery, perhaps—and tell them the truth of what you're feeling, without trying to fix anything yet, without explaining or justifying... what do you think would happen? Not to solve the problem, but just to stop carrying it alone?